The short answer
- Ingredients
- Sherbet Cane Straw, Butter, Milk and any grain. Wheat is the cheap pick for the grain.
- Stars
- Four stars, a dessert. It’s already in your cookbook when the narwhal asks for it.
- Where
- Straw seeds at Goofy’s Stall in Candy Cove. Butter and Milk from Chez Remy in the Valley.
- Needed for
- 2 for the narwhal in Captain Hook’s quest I Can Speak Whale, plus the “Whip up cake pops” riddle in the Trial of Expression. Each is +1,367 energy or 787 Star Coins.
- 4
- Ingredients
- 4 stars
- Dessert
- +1,367
- Energy
- 787
- Sells for
- 2
- For the narwhal
- Nov 2026
- Checked on
Cute Cake Pops use one Candy Cove crop and three things you can buy or grow in the Valley
| Ingredient | Where to get it | Good to know |
|---|---|---|
| Sherbet Cane Straw | Seeds at Goofy’s Stall in Candy Cove | About 30 minutes to grow. Each plant should give two stalks |
| Butter | Chez Remy, or Tiana’s Palace if you’ve reopened it | 190 Star Coins each |
| Milk | Chez Remy or Tiana’s Palace | 230 Star Coins each |
| Any grain | Wheat from Goofy’s Stall in the Peaceful Meadow, or any Rice you have stored | Wheat grows in about a minute and costs next to nothing |
The straw is the only slow part, and you can’t forage it, so plant it the moment the Candy Cove stall opens. You’ll want it for Hook’s wreck repair anyway.
Buy the Butter and Milk at Chez Remy before you sail out, so you can cook the whole batch on the ship. One cake pop costs 420 coins in dairy. The game counts Sherbet Cane Straw as a grain, so a second stalk should fill the grain slot, but a stalk sells for 103 and Wheat for 2. Use Wheat.
Any cooking station works, including the stove in the Captain’s Cabin on your ship. More on growing the straw is in our Sherbet Cane Straw guide.
The narwhal at Sweetwater Wharf wants 2 Cute Cake Pops and 2 Candied Oyster
In I Can Speak Whale, you repair Captain Hook’s wrecked ship with Rock Candy, Sherbet Cane Straw and 15 Gummy Beans. Then you equip Dory, swim out to the giant narwhal and let her translate. The narwhal is too hungry to move and says she’s “quite fond of candied oysters and cake pops”.
She wants two of each. Both recipes are already in your cookbook at this point, so there’s no recipe item to find or open. Cook all four in one go and hand them over. One cake pop isn’t enough to clear the step. Once she’s fed, she moves off the whirlpool that leads to Sunken Echo: The Cookie Cutters.
Candied Oyster is an Oyster and a Gummy Bean. Goofy’s Stall in Candy Cove sells the Oysters, and the beans lie on the ground around Candy Cove. Count 17 beans for the whole quest: 15 for the repair and 2 for the oysters. Every step is in our Captain Hook unlock guide.
The Guardian of Expression asks for more cake pops, so cook five or more in one batch
Soon after the narwhal, once you place the three Candy Cove Keepsakes, the Guardian of Expression’s trial opens, and one of its riddles is “Whip up cake pops”. The count should be around three, though it may be higher. Another riddle in the same trial is “Harvest Sherbet Cane Straw”, so a full row of straw ticks that off too.
Cooking seven in one sitting is the easy way to cover both quests: two for the narwhal and five for the riddle. That’s seven stalks, seven Wheat, and 2,940 coins of Butter and Milk from Chez Remy. Plant one extra row of straw on top of what Hook’s repair takes. All of the riddles are in our Guardian Trials guide.
Cute Cake Pops are the best-selling Keepsake Sea dessert at 787 coins
No other new dessert sells for more. Crepe Cone, which also uses the straw, fetches 593, and Mermaid Milkshake 446. With 420 coins of dairy and a stalk you could have sold for 103, each pop clears about 260 coins over its parts, so it’s a decent seller rather than a money maker. Eaten, +1,367 is solid but Crepe Cone gives +1,680.
Other dishes that use your straw: Crepe Cone, Ice Cream Sandwich and Cute Sugar Cookies. The full menu is in our Keepsake Sea recipes guide, and the rest of the expansion is in our Keepsake Sea guide.
FAQ
How do you make Cute Cake Pops in Dreamlight Valley?
Cook 1 Sherbet Cane Straw, 1 Butter, 1 Milk and 1 of any grain at a cooking station. Wheat is the easiest grain.
Do I need to unlock the Cute Cake Pops recipe?
No. It’s already in your cookbook by the time the narwhal asks for it.
How many Cute Cake Pops does the narwhal need?
Two, along with two Candied Oyster.
Where do I get Butter and Milk in Keepsake Sea?
Buy them at Chez Remy back in the Valley, or at Tiana’s Palace if it’s open.
Source & credit
Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is developed and published by Gameloft. The recipe card and star rating were checked in CupcakeIsGaming’s How to make ALL Keepsake Sea RECIPES!! video. The narwhal’s request, the recipe already being known and the Trial of Expression riddles come from launch playthroughs by Probably Senpai and MrStarInSky. Energy, sell values, shop prices and grow times come from the Dreamlight Valley Wiki.


