The short answer
- Ingredients
- Anchovy, Butter and any spice. Basil, Oregano or Mint all fit the spice slot.
- Stars
- Three stars. It’s an appetizer: +878 energy, sells for 322 Star Coins.
- Anchovy
- Ordinary fishing in any of the four Shipwreck Shores areas. You’ll often catch them just swimming around Barnacle Bay.
- Unlock
- Nothing to learn first. Cook the three together and Bagna Càuda joins your collection.
- 3
- Ingredients
- 3 stars
- Appetizer
- +878
- Energy
- 322
- Sells for
- 2 min
- Read time
- Nov 2026
- Checked on
The recipe card spells it Bagna Càuda, with a grave accent, so you’ll also see it written as plain Bagna Cauda. It’s an anchovy and butter dip, and every part of it is cheap once you’ve reached the first island.
The Anchovy comes from Shipwreck Shores, the Butter from Chez Remy
| Ingredient | Where | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Anchovy | Open water or white ripples in Barnacle Bay, Peddler’s Post, the Infernal Fortress and Galleon Gulf | Common. Sells for only 25 raw |
| Butter | Chez Remy in the Valley, or Tiana’s Palace | 190 Star Coins each. Bring a few with you |
| Any spice | Basil in Peaceful Meadow, Oregano around the Plaza, Mint in Frosted Heights; Garlic, Ginger and Cinnamon also count | Luminous Hibiscus is classed as a spice too, so it should fill the slot without leaving Shipwreck Shores |
The Anchovy slot is named, so no other fish works there. Butter is the same: Milk, Cheese or Egg won’t swap in.
Bagna Càuda turns a 25-coin Anchovy into a 322-coin plate
Raw Anchovies are close to worthless at the stall, and you’ll pull a lot of them while hunting other fish. This is the best thing to do with the extras. Even counting the 190 you pay Remy for Butter, each plate clears more than a hundred Star Coins over the ingredients, and +878 energy is plenty for a stretch of sea-combing.
Save some Anchovies for other dishes before you cook a big batch. Sea Biscuit, which the Skeleton Captain wants in Captain of the Dead, uses one, as do Sushi Ship Platter and Treasure Map Pizza. No quest or Guardian riddle asks for Bagna Càuda itself.
All 37 new meals, with their island ingredients, are in our Keepsake Sea recipes guide.
FAQ
How do you make Bagna Càuda in Dreamlight Valley?
Cook 1 Anchovy, 1 Butter and 1 of any spice at any cooking station, including the stove in your ship’s Captain’s Cabin.
Where do I find Anchovies?
Any fishing spot in Shipwreck Shores. They’re common, so a few minutes of swimming over ripples near Barnacle Bay should be enough.
Where do I get Butter for it?
Chez Remy or Tiana’s Palace in the Valley, at 190 Star Coins each. Carry a few over and keep them in the Captain’s Cabin storage.
Is Bagna Càuda worth selling?
Yes, compared with selling the raw Anchovy. At 322 it pays more than any other appetizer that uses Anchovy.
Source & credit
Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is developed and published by Gameloft. The recipe card spelling, star rating and New Recipe banner were checked in CupcakeIsGaming’s How to make ALL Keepsake Sea RECIPES!! video. Energy, sell values, the spice list and Anchovy spots come from the Dreamlight Valley Wiki.


