Walkthrough

Dreamlight Valley Keepsake Sea No Pirates Allowed: Full Quest Walkthrough

Disney Dreamlight Valley screenshot

The short answer

Where it starts
Captain Hook‘s quest, right after you wake the Guardian of Expression with three Keepsakes in Candy Cove.
What you need
8 of the 13 Trial of Expression riddles, then 1 Gourd-geous Casserole, 1 Taro Turtle Bread and 2 Mermaid Milkshake in the Kingdom of Oublié.
Plant early
Buy Mermaid Gourd and Twilight Taro seeds at Goofy’s Stall on the Coral Coast as soon as you land. Both take most of an hour to grow.
How it ends
Catch the large fish by Hook’s ship, then place and build the Jolly Roger. The Pinky Promise starts straight after.
Jump to every step
8 of 13
Riddles to pass
4
Dishes to cook
1
Large fish
~1 hr
Crop wait
6 min
Read time
Nov 20 2026
Checked on

No Pirates Allowed opens once the Guardian of Expression is awake

You get it after Sunken Echo: The Cookie Cutters, when you put the three Candy Cove Keepsakes on the Guardian of Expression’s pedestal. She won’t let you into the Kingdom of Oublié until you pass her trial, even though Hook has already sailed past. The quest log lists it under Captain Hook.

Megara’s first friendship quest shows up as an optional step. It doesn’t block anything. Her quests are in our Megara guide, and every earlier story quest is in our Keepsake Sea walkthrough.

Every No Pirates Allowed step, in tracker order

Quoted lines are the tracker’s wording.

  1. “Overcome the Guardian of Expression’s Trial to progress.” Open the Guardian Trials menu (U on PC) and solve 8 riddles.
  2. “Talk to the Guardian of Expression on her island in Sweetwater Wharf.”
  3. “Sail through the tunnel next to the Guardian of Expression’s island and dock in the Kingdom of Oublié.” The tunnel is a cave opening beside her island, easy to sail past.
  4. “Explore the Coral Coast for any signs of your old friend.”
  5. “The gate to the Grand Garden is locked. Find a way to open the gate. There must be some clues around the Coral Coast.” Solve the colored plate puzzle (below).
  6. “The gate is opened! Search for the mysterious “W” in the Grand Garden.”
  7. “Search for a strange tablet between the waterfall and the gate to the Grand Garden.” Pick it up and bring it to Captain Hook. He should be in a cage close by.
  8. “Prepare a meal for Jack and Hook”: Gourd-geous Casserole 0/1, Taro Turtle Bread 0/1, Mermaid Milkshake 0/2. Read the recipe books next to Hook first.
  9. Hand Hook the food. He tells you about a big fish.
  10. “Hook mentioned a large fish near his ship in the waters off the Coral Coast. Catch it using your merfolk abilities.” Swim behind his ship and grab it, then bring it back to him.
  11. “Hook has agreed to dry dock his ship as a show of good faith. Place the foundations of the Jolly Roger.” Use furniture mode, pay Scrooge McDuck at the sign, build it and talk to Hook.

Eight of the Guardian of Expression’s 13 riddles open the way

The gauge passes at 8, so skip anything slow. These go fastest, and all of them happen in Candy Cove:

  • Plant 10 seeds. Any seeds from Goofy’s Stall. You don’t have to grow them.
  • Place 10 items in furniture mode. Anything counts, candy landscaping included.
  • Mine 5 times at the Candy Cove mining spots.
  • Harvest Mapleberry, the “very sugary berry”. The bushes show on your map.
  • Cook 3 Cute Cake Pops. The riddle says “cake pops” but means this dish.
  • Get Jack Sparrow to friendship level 5. Gems and flowers are fine as gifts if you’re close.
  • Photo of Hook’s hideout. It counts at the little sugar skull in Peppermint Plaza where you found the pirate map, not on Donut Island.

Clamshell pearls respawn slowly, so leave that riddle. The full list of 13 is in our Guardian Trials guide.

Megara, Jack Sparrow and Milo stand on a green stone pier at dusk beside Milo's submarine, with Dory in the purple water and a large setting sun behind them
Your crew follows you into the Kingdom of Oublié in this quest. From the official Keepsake Sea trailer on Steam.

The Grand Garden gate opens when you count the branches on each clue

Around the Coral Coast you’ll find round floor plates with colored gems. Each gem has branches coming off its sides. The clue near them reads “count the branches to know the order”: the number of branches on each gem is its slot on the gate, and the gate’s slots are marked with Roman numerals. If the gate rejects your order, walk back to the plates and recount.

Hook’s meal takes Mermaid Gourd and Twilight Taro, so plant both first

You learn all three recipes from the books next to Hook. Cook at any stove with autofill.

DishHow manyIngredients
Gourd-geous Casserole1Unicorn Fish, Mermaid Gourd, Cheese, any vegetable, any spice
Taro Turtle Bread1Wheat, Twilight Taro
Mermaid Milkshake2Milk, Pomegranate, any fruit, any sweet
  • Mermaid Gourd and Twilight Taro: seeds at Goofy’s Stall on the Coral Coast, by the green steps up to the Grand Garden. Plant them before you fish or pick fruit. Mermaid Gourd takes about 40 minutes, so start the taro at the same time. Details in our Mermaid Gourd guide.
  • Unicorn Fish: fishing ripples in the Oublié waters.
  • Pomegranate: the fruit trees on the Coral Coast. Each tree gives two, and they’re slow to regrow. Take every one you pass, since the Guardian of Boldness and Wendy’s Narwhal Treat want more later.
  • Milk, Cheese, Wheat, a vegetable, a spice, a fruit and a sweet: bring them from the Valley. Banana and Sugarcane fit the milkshake’s open slots.

The milkshake has its own page in our Mermaid Milkshake guide, and every new dish is in our Keepsake Sea recipes guide.

The large fish sits behind Hook’s ship, and the Jolly Roger goes where you found him

Dive in merfolk form off the Coral Coast near Hook’s wrecked ship. The fish should be around the back of the ship. Grab it and carry it to Hook.

He then agrees to dry dock the Jolly Roger. Open furniture mode and place the foundations; the spot where you found Hook works. Pay Scrooge McDuck at the sign, build it, then talk to Hook to finish the quest.

The Pinky Promise starts the moment No Pirates Allowed ends

It appears as a Mystery quest: “The magical curse is lifted. Return to the Grand Garden to find your old friend.” That old friend is Wendy. Her full route, from here to her house, is in our Wendy guide.

The hideout photo and a full inventory are the usual snags

  • The Hook’s hideout photo won’t count: a photo of Donut Island or Hook’s wrecked boat doesn’t register. Use the small sugar skull among the candy buildings in Peppermint Plaza.
  • Cake pops riddle won’t tick: it wants Cute Cake Pops. If the recipe isn’t in your list, pick other riddles.
  • “Inventory is full” while cooking or fishing: each meal and the fish need a free slot. Clear space before you start the meal step.

Other launch bugs are in our Keepsake Sea bugs guide.

FAQ

How many riddles do I need for the Guardian of Expression?

8 of the 13. Seeds, decor, mining, Mapleberry, Cute Cake Pops, Jack at level 5 and the hideout photo are the quickest.

What goes in the meal for Jack and Hook?

1 Gourd-geous Casserole (Unicorn Fish, Mermaid Gourd, Cheese, any vegetable, any spice), 1 Taro Turtle Bread (Wheat, Twilight Taro) and 2 Mermaid Milkshake (Milk, Pomegranate, any fruit, any sweet).

Do I need Megara’s friendship quest?

No. It’s an optional step and the quest finishes without it.

Checklist

0 of 8

Source & credit

Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is developed and published by Gameloft. Quest steps and tracker text come from YouTube videos by Quick Tips and MrStarInSky; the gate tip comes from an r/DreamlightValley thread. The image is from the official Keepsake Sea trailer on Steam. Every Keepsake Sea guide we have is in our Dreamlight Valley Keepsake Sea guide.

Did this help you find what you were looking for?

Next for Disney Dreamlight Valley