The short answer
- Where they are
- The Guardian’s Trials tab at the top of the Dreamlight menu (U on PC). Each statue Guardian gives one trial, a list of riddles that are really plain tasks.
- Trial of Discovery
- Seven riddles in Barnacle Bay: plant seeds, cleanse Cursed Anemones, mine with the Royal Pickaxe, haul up treasures, photograph the Guardian, place the Cooking Station and the Crafting Station.
- Trial of Resilience
- The one with the shark tail. Riddles include a photo of a very big skull, pirate ship treasure, decorating Doubloon Depths, popping bubbles, cooking Kraken’s Catch and gifting Jack 5 favourite things.
- Passing vs full reward
- You pass a trial before finishing every riddle, at 5 of 7 for Discovery. Finish all of them for the Guardian’s final prize, a merfolk tail.
- 7
- Discovery riddles
- 5 of 7
- To pass Discovery
- Shark tail
- Resilience prize
- U
- Menu key on PC
- 5 min
- Read time
- Nov 2026
- Checked on

Guardian Trials sit in the Dreamlight menu and replace Duties while you are in the Keepsake Sea
Trials start during The Four Guardians quest. After you put the Bottled Binoculars on the empty pedestal under the mermaid statue, the Guardian of Discovery wakes and sets her riddles, and Milo hands you a cooking pot and a crafting station. Our Keepsake Sea guide covers the quest order around it.
- Open it: Dreamlight menu, then Guardian’s Trials, the first tab on the left. There is also a separate Keepsake Sea tab of regular Duties lower down.
- The gauge: the bar across the top fills with each riddle you solve. A check mark on the bar shows the pass point, and the Claim button at the end pays out the final prize once every riddle is done.
- Tracking: you can track a single riddle on screen, but not the whole trial at once.
- Turning in: once you pass, the quest sends you back to that Guardian’s grotto to talk to her. That step is what moves the story on.
Trial of Discovery has seven riddles, all in Barnacle Bay
The Guardian of Discovery’s grotto is in Barnacle Bay in Shipwreck Shores. Every riddle here uses tools you already have.
| Riddle as written | What to do | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Use your Shovel and plant some seeds | Plant any seeds. Goofy’s stall in the Keepsake Sea sells Dreamlight Avocado and Sweet Heart of Palm seeds if you are out. | 5 |
| Use your Dreamlight Magic on some tricky Cursed Anemone | Clear the Cursed Anemones around Barnacle Bay. They respawn, so clearing some before the trial starts does not lock you out. | 5 |
| Put your Royal Pickaxe to use in Barnacle Bay | Mine rocks inside Barnacle Bay. | 5 |
| Haul up treasures from the waters around Barnacle Bay | Fish or pull up treasure from the water around the bay. | 5 |
| Use a mechanical eye to capture an image of a Guardian in her grotto | Take a photo of the Guardian statue with your camera. | 1 |
| Decorate in Barnacle Bay by placing the Cooking Station given to you by a clever cartographer | Place Milo’s cooking pot anywhere in Barnacle Bay. | 1 |
| Decorate in Barnacle Bay by placing the Crafting Station | Place the crafting station Milo gave you in Barnacle Bay. | 1 |
Five riddles pass the trial. Do all seven and claim the gauge for the Guardian of Discovery’s final prize, a merfolk tail piece for your swimming form. Then go back to her grotto to finish the step.

Trial of Resilience pays out the shark tail and needs Jack Sparrow
The Guardian of Resilience guards the waters to Candy Cove; you sail to her island on your pirate ship once Jack has joined you. Her trial is longer than Discovery’s and is the one players are working through for the shark tail.
| Riddle | What to do |
|---|---|
| Take a picture of a very big skull somewhere in Shipwreck Shores | It’s in Peddler’s Post, just before the gate of the Infernal Fortress. Stand back far enough to fit it in frame and take the photo with your camera. |
| Use your pirate ship to scavenge treasures from around Shipwreck Shores | Sail the ship and pick up the treasure spots around Shipwreck Shores. |
| Make the Doubloon Depths feel more like home by decorating beneath the waves | Swim down to the Doubloon Depths and place furniture underwater. |
| Pop some bubbles beneath the waves | Swim into the floating bubbles in the Doubloon Depths. |
| Harvest a colorful fruit with a hard shell from Shipwreck Shores | Harvest the shelled fruit that grows in Shipwreck Shores. |
| Cook a meal fit for a pirate captain | Cook Kraken’s Catch. Jack gives you the recipe in Captain of the Dead; open it from your inventory or the dish comes out as Grilled Fish. Ingredients are in our Keepsake Sea recipes guide. |
| Gift Jack 5 favorite things | Give Jack Sparrow five of his favourite gifts. Details below. |
The full Resilience list and its pass point are still being checked. When you pass, return to the Guardian of Resilience in her grotto and she opens the way to Candy Cove.
Gifting Jack 5 favourite things
If Jack’s favourites are items you cannot get yet, reroll them. Duplicates of the same favourite count toward the five, but you may need to spread them across days, and leaving the area and coming back can let you give another. Opening up more of the Keepsake Sea may give you access to more of his favourites. Our Jack Sparrow unlock guide covers how he joins. For critter “favourite food” tasks, feeding one critter its favourite five times can count.
The Guardians of Expression, Boldness and Belief come later
The Keepsake Sea has three more Guardian islands: The Guardian of Expression, The Guardian of Boldness and The Guardian of Belief. Their riddle lists and prizes are still being checked. Like all questing islands, they do not hold furniture, so anything you place there is moved to the nearest spot that does.
Mistakes with Guardian Trials
- Mistake: Stopping at the pass point. Fix: The merfolk tail prize only unlocks when every riddle in the trial is done.
- Mistake: Cooking Grilled Fish for the pirate captain riddle. Fix: Open the Kraken’s Catch recipe from your inventory first so the dish registers.
- Mistake: Red dot on Duties you cannot claim. Fix: Finish the Guardian of Discovery’s riddles first; that should unlock claiming. For normal Duties, return to your main Valley.
- Mistake: Skipping fishing tasks underwater. Fix: Fishing in merfolk form should count toward “fish without failing” Duties too.
FAQ
How do I get the shark tail in Dreamlight Valley Keepsake Sea?
Complete every riddle in the Guardian of Resilience’s Trial of Resilience, then claim the final prize on the trial gauge.
What is a meal fit for a pirate captain?
Kraken’s Catch. Jack Sparrow gives you the recipe during Captain of the Dead.
Where are my Dreamlight Duties in the Keepsake Sea?
The Dreamlight page shows Guardian’s Trials while you are there. Return to your main Valley and the regular Duties come back.
How many riddles does the Trial of Discovery have?
Seven. Five pass the trial, all seven earn the final prize.
Do Cursed Anemones respawn if I cleared them early?
They should come back, so you can still finish the anemone riddle.
Checklist
0 of 9
Source & credit
Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is developed and published by Gameloft. Riddle lists were cross-checked against launch-day playthroughs by Tinkerlily, Serroh, Eveaxia and Letz Play K, threads on r/DreamlightValley, and the Gameloft Help Center. Images are from the official Keepsake Sea trailer.



