The short answer
- Ingredients
- Milk, Pomegranate, any fruit and any sweet. Banana and Sugarcane both work for the open slots.
- Stars
- Four stars, a dessert worth +1,686 energy or 446 Star Coins.
- Pomegranate
- Picked from Pomegranate trees in the Kingdom of Oublié, the third island, so the milkshake waits until the story takes you there.
- Quest
- No Pirates Allowed wants two, along with a Gourd-geous Casserole and a Taro Turtle Bread. You learn all three from the recipe books in that quest.
- 4
- Ingredients
- 4 stars
- Dessert
- +1,686
- Energy
- 446
- Sells for
- 2
- For No Pirates Allowed
- Nov 2026
- Checked on
Milk and the sweet come from the Valley, the Pomegranate from Oublié
For the quest you need two of everything: 2 Milk, 2 Pomegranates, 2 fruit and 2 sweets.
| Slot | Where to get it |
|---|---|
| Milk | Buy it at Chez Remy, or at Tiana’s Palace once it’s open |
| Pomegranate | Pomegranate trees around the Kingdom of Oublié; there should be some on the Coral Coast, where you first land. Each tree gives two, then should take about 30 minutes to fruit again |
| Any fruit | Banana fits. So should Lychee from the tree by the Barnacle Bay Wishing Well, or Mapleberry from Candy Cove |
| Any sweet | Sugarcane from Goofy’s Stall seeds in Dazzle Beach (about 7 minutes to grow), Cocoa Bean from the Cacao Trees in Glade of Trust or Sunlit Plateau, or foraged Vanilla |
Pack the Milk and the sweet before you sail. Pomegranate is the only part you have to pick on the island.
No Pirates Allowed asks for two Mermaid Milkshakes for Jack and Hook
After you bring Captain Hook the strange tablet from between the waterfall and the Grand Garden gate, he wants a meal for himself and Jack Sparrow: 1 Gourd-geous Casserole, 1 Taro Turtle Bread and 2 Mermaid Milkshakes. Read each of the recipe books nearby before you cook. That should be how the milkshake gets into your recipe list.
The casserole is the slow one, since Mermaid Gourd takes around 40 minutes to grow. Our Mermaid Gourd guide covers it, and the Keepsake Sea walkthrough has the quest step by step.
FAQ
How do you make Mermaid Milkshake in Dreamlight Valley?
Cook Milk, Pomegranate, any fruit and any sweet together after reading its recipe book in No Pirates Allowed.
Can I make it before reaching the Kingdom of Oublié?
Not with your own harvest. Pomegranate only grows in Oublié, and the recipe comes from that island’s quest.
Does the Pomegranate count as the fruit?
It fills its own named slot. Put a second fruit, such as a Banana, in the “any fruit” slot.
Is it worth selling?
At 446 Star Coins it’s mid-range. The +1,686 energy is the better use once the quest is done.
Source & credit
Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is developed and published by Gameloft. The recipe card, star rating and the Milk, Pomegranate, Sugarcane and Banana combination were checked in CupcakeIsGaming’s How to make ALL Keepsake Sea RECIPES!! video. No Pirates Allowed steps come from launch-week quest videos. Energy, sell value and ingredient sources come from the Dreamlight Valley Wiki. Every other new dish is in our Keepsake Sea recipes guide.


