Walkthrough

Dreamlight Valley Keepsake Sea Trial of Resilience: All 17 Riddles, the Big Skull and the Shark Tail

Disney Dreamlight Valley screenshot

The short answer

Very, very big skull
It’s the rock skull with a waterfall pouring out of it, at the top of Peddler’s Post by the archway into the Infernal Fortress. Stand by the Peddler’s Post well, face north and take the photo.
Colorful fruit with a hard shell
Dreamlight Avocado, and you need 10. Buy the seeds at Goofy’s Stall in Barnacle Bay and harvest them after the riddle shows up.
Meal fit for a pirate captain
Cook two Kraken’s Catch.
Pass or finish
The trial has 17 riddles. About half of them pass it and open the way to Candy Cove. Finish all 17 and press Claim for the shark tail.
Jump to all 17 riddles
17
Riddles
8 to 10
To pass
Shark tail
Final prize
Shipwreck Shores
Where
8 min
Read time
Nov 2026
Checked on

The Trial of Resilience opens when you put three Keepsakes on her altar

It’s the second Guardian trial, and it starts near the end of The Enchanted Ship, right after you get your pirate ship.

Once the ship is repaired and Jack Sparrow is at the Bow, sail to the Guardian of Resilience’s island. Place your three Keepsakes on the Altar of Resilience in her grotto, then talk to her. She wakes up and sets you her riddles. The Enchanted Ship wraps up with Jack’s house, and the next story quest, A Slippery Situation, opens with the step “Complete the Guardian of Resilience’s Riddles.”

The riddles live in the Dreamlight menu (U on PC) under the Guardian’s Trials tab. You can switch between the Discovery and Resilience lists, and pin one riddle at a time to your screen.

The bar along the top fills as you solve riddles. When it reaches the marker partway along, you get a “Trial passed” message. That marker should sit at around 8 to 10 riddles. If you want the ship and its parts first, our Enchanted Ship parts guide has every piece.

All 17 Trial of Resilience riddles and their answers

Riddles are worded the way the trial panel shows them, in the order they appear. Count is how many times you have to do it.

RiddleAnswerCount
Take a picture of a very, very big skull somewhere in Shipwreck ShoresPhotograph the skull-shaped rock with the waterfall at the top of Peddler’s Post, by the Infernal Fortress archway. Steps in the skull section.1
Use your pirate ship to scavenge treasures from the waters around Shipwreck ShoresSail onto a large ripple with floating debris and salvage it with the ship’s claw.5
Pop some bubbles beneath the wavesSwim through the floating bubbles underwater in merfolk form.20
Make the Doubloon Depths feel more like home by decorating beneath the wavesPlace furniture underwater in the Doubloon Depths.10
Harvest a colorful fruit with a hard shell from Shipwreck ShoresDreamlight Avocado. Lychee and the other fruit don’t count.10
Cook a meal fit for a pirate captainKraken’s Catch.2
Mine a very special barnacle from the rocks around Shipwreck ShoresCrystalline Barnacle, from mining rocks anywhere in Shipwreck Shores.5
Spend some time with a cartographer and linguistHang out with Milo Thatch.15 min
Spend some time with a dishonest honest pirate captainHang out with Jack Sparrow.15 min
Harvest a red berry from Shipwreck ShoresLychee. The first tree is next to the Wishing Well in Barnacle Bay.20
Rebuild the dockyard trading post in Barnacle BayRepair the Dockyard Trading Post on the Barnacle Bay waterfront.1
Restore a place to shop and spend your loot in Peddler’s PostRestore Scrooge McDuck’s store in Peddler’s Post.1
Restore a place to gather and eat in Peddler’s PostRestore Chez Remy in Peddler’s Post.1
Serve food to some hungry customersFill restaurant orders. Chez Remy works once it’s restored.5
Give a pirate captain one of his favorite thingsGive Jack Sparrow his favorite gifts.5
Befriend a bird with a very big beak in Shipwreck ShoresBefriend a Toucan. One Lychee does it.1
Reach a triple-level friendship with a Villager obsessed with AtlantisGet Milo Thatch to friendship level 3.Level 3

To pass fast, clear the one-offs first: the skull photo, the three restorations, two Kraken’s Catch and a Toucan. Add five barnacles and five scavenges and you should be at the pass marker. The Lychee, avocado and bubble counts are the long ones, so keep them for the full clear.

The very, very big skull is the waterfall rock above Peddler’s Post

This one sends people sailing around the whole island. The skull isn’t out at sea. It’s a giant rock carved like a skull with water pouring out of it, up the hill at the north end of Peddler’s Post, right next to the archway that leads into the Infernal Fortress.

  1. Travel to Peddler’s Post, the part of Shipwreck Shores with Scrooge’s store.
  2. Walk to the well, then turn to face north, toward the Infernal Fortress.
  3. Look up the hill. The skull with the waterfall sits just off the path, beside the archway.
  4. Open your camera from the tool wheel and take a photo with the whole skull in frame.

If it doesn’t count, back up and shoot again with more of the skull in view. Don’t confuse it with the Floating Skulls from Captain of the Dead, which are small green skulls that drift around Peddler’s Post and Barnacle Bay. Our Floating Skulls guide covers those.

An underwater seabed of pink sand and coral with a cluster of domed shell houses, kelp and fish under shafts of light
The Keepsake Sea seabed, where the bubble and decorating riddles happen. Official Keepsake Sea trailer.

The hard-shelled fruit is Dreamlight Avocado, and only fresh ones count

“Harvest a colorful fruit with a hard shell from Shipwreck Shores” stumps people because Lychee looks like the answer. It isn’t. The riddle wants Dreamlight Avocado, and it wants 10 of them.

  • Buy Dreamlight Avocado seeds at Goofy’s Stall in Barnacle Bay.
  • Plant them in Shipwreck Shores. They take about 5 minutes to grow.
  • Harvest after the riddle is on your list. Avocados you picked before you woke the Guardian of Resilience don’t count, so sitting on a stack in your bag won’t help.

Plant 12 if you can. Each Kraken’s Catch takes one avocado too, and you need two of those for the pirate captain riddle.

The pirate captain meal is two Kraken’s Catch

Kraken’s Catch takes a Mini-Kraken, a Dreamlight Avocado, any dairy or oil (Egg, Milk, Butter or Cheese) and any fruit. The Mini-Kraken is the legendary fish in Shipwreck Shores, caught from gold ripples or gold bubbles, so a fishing potion helps.

Jack Sparrow gives you the recipe through the Infernal Fortress door in Captain of the Dead. If your stove makes Grilled Fish instead, open the recipe from your inventory first, then cook again. Cooking two is enough, there’s nothing to hand in. The full walkthrough for this riddle is in our meal fit for a pirate captain guide, and every other new dish is in the Keepsake Sea recipes guide.

A player in a feathered pirate hat and white blouse standing on a stone dock at night, with a pirate ship flying a Mickey skull flag moored behind
Your pirate ship does the scavenging riddle. Official Keepsake Sea trailer.

Scavenging works when the claw at the back hangs over the ripple

“Use your pirate ship to scavenge treasures” needs five salvages. Out on the water, look for large ripples with debris floating in them. Sail past the ripple until the back of the ship, where the salvage claw hangs, sits over it, then press the salvage button (R2 on PlayStation).

“You can’t scavenge here” means the claw isn’t over the spot yet. Nudge forward and press again. An active fishing potion or enchanted rod can block it too, so let those run out first. If the button shows and nothing happens however you line up, try restarting the game.

Bubbles and decor both happen down in the Doubloon Depths

Switch to merfolk form and dive. Popping 20 bubbles just means swimming through the floating ones. They come back after a short wait, so place furniture while they respawn.

For the decor riddle, open furniture mode while you’re underwater and place 10 items in the Doubloon Depths. The riddle says beneath the waves, so do it on the seabed, not on the beach. The Doubloon Depths guide covers getting down there, and the merfolk form guide has the swim controls.

Jack wants gifts from islands you can’t reach yet, so skip him to pass

Three riddles lean on villagers. The two hangouts take 15 minutes each, with Milo and with Jack. Start one before you go farming avocados or Lychee, since the timer runs while you do other riddles.

Milo to friendship level 3 comes from talking to him, gifting him and the hangout itself, so do this one alongside his 15 minutes. How he joins and where he lives are in our Milo Thatch guide.

Jack’s five favorite gifts are the snag. His list often asks for things like Mermaid Gourd or Mint Neapolitan Oxalis, and those come from Candy Cove and the Kingdom of Oublié, which this trial is what opens. You don’t need this riddle to pass. You can reroll his favorites once a day until they land on Shipwreck Shores items, and giving the same favorite twice counts, though you may have to spread the five over a couple of days. Our Jack Sparrow guide has more on him.

Claim the shark tail from the menu once all 17 are done

  1. Pass the trial, then return to the Guardian of Resilience in her grotto near the dock and talk to her. That’s what moves A Slippery Situation on and opens the way to Candy Cove.
  2. Keep going with the story if you like. The unfinished riddles stay on the Guardian’s Trials tab.
  3. When the gauge is full, open the Dreamlight menu, go to Guardian’s Trials, pick Resilience and press Claim at the end of the bar. You don’t have to sail back to her for this part.

The prize is a shark merfolk tail, which should show up as Starry Shark Vertical in your fin options. Change your look from the merfolk form wardrobe. The Discovery tail and the later trials are in our Guardian Trials guide.

Fixes for the Resilience riddles that won’t tick

  • Mistake: Harvesting avocados before the riddle appeared. Fix: Those don’t count. Plant a fresh batch of 10 and harvest after.
  • Mistake: Hunting the skull out at sea. Fix: It’s on land, up the hill from the Peddler’s Post well by the Infernal Fortress archway.
  • Mistake: Cooking Grilled Fish. Fix: Open the Kraken’s Catch recipe from your inventory, then cook two.
  • Mistake: Decorating the beach. Fix: The decor riddle wants furniture placed underwater in the Doubloon Depths.
  • Mistake: Waiting on Jack’s gifts before talking to the Guardian. Fix: Pass with the other riddles, open Candy Cove, then come back for his favorites.
  • Mistake: Running out of customers. Fix: The order line should refill within the hour, so the last couple may need a wait.

FAQ

Where is the very, very big skull in Shipwreck Shores?

At the north end of Peddler’s Post, up the hill beside the archway into the Infernal Fortress. It’s a skull-shaped rock with a waterfall coming out of it. From the well, face north and take the photo.

What is the colorful fruit with a hard shell in Dreamlight Valley?

Dreamlight Avocado. You need 10, harvested after the riddle shows up. Seeds are at Goofy’s Stall in Barnacle Bay.

What is the red berry from Shipwreck Shores?

Lychee. The riddle wants 20, and the closest tree is next to the Wishing Well in Barnacle Bay.

How many riddles do I need to pass the Trial of Resilience?

Around half of the 17, roughly 8 to 10. Watch for the “Trial passed” message, then talk to the Guardian in her grotto.

How do I get the shark tail in Dreamlight Valley?

Finish all 17 Trial of Resilience riddles, then press Claim at the end of the gauge in the Guardian’s Trials tab.

What is the very special barnacle?

Crystalline Barnacle, a gem from mining rocks in Shipwreck Shores. You need five, and Shiny Crystalline Barnacles should count too.

Checklist

0 of 10

Source & credit

Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is developed and published by Gameloft. Riddle wording and counts were cross-checked against the Dreamlight Valley Wiki, launch-week streams by Serroh, Probably Senpai, MrStarInSky and Letz Play K, and threads on r/DreamlightValley. Images are from the official Keepsake Sea trailer.

Did this help you find what you were looking for?

Next for Disney Dreamlight Valley