WoW: Forever’s Blackmaw Hold gold farm paid 160 an hour before Blizzard silently nerfed it, raising fears about the economy

Non-elite furbolgs dropped full loot until Monday. The fix is missing from the hotfix notes, and the thousands of gold players farmed are still in the game.

Blackmaw furbolgs kneeling before a shrine inside Blackmaw Hold in WoW: Forever

For a few days after World of Warcraft: Forever’s first players hit level 60, one group of furbolgs in the new Blackmaw Hold dungeon was the best gold in the game. Level 60 mages were soloing packs of non-elite mobs there for a claimed 160 gold an hour, and some players walked away with thousands of gold before Blizzard turned the loot off on Monday, November 16.

WoW: Forever's Blackmaw Hold gold farm has been nerfed, but not before players made a ton of goldWatch the short YouTube
The 30-second version. Subscribe on YouTube for more.

The farm is dead now, but the gold isn’t. Blizzard hasn’t said whether anyone will lose what they made, and the change doesn’t appear in its official hotfix notes. Two weeks into a game where Blizzard has been deliberately stingy with gold, that has players worried about the economy for months to come.

Our guide: World of Warcraft: Forever fishing guide: skill caps, the Fish Bowl and the broken Fishing Rack

Non-elite Blackmaw Devotees dropped full loot, worth 50 silver a kill

Blackmaw Hold is one of Forever’s new max-level dungeons, a 55 to 60 instance in Azshara where the furbolgs of the Blackmaw clan are fighting a corruption spreading through their groves. Its trash includes packs of level 56 non-elite Blackmaw Devotees, and those mobs dropped full loot: coin plus gray weapons that sell to a vendor for a surprising amount.

Players on Reddit said the Blackmaw mobs were missing the drop penalty other dungeons have. “Kill a mob in LBRS, it drops 5s, kill a mob in Blackmaw it drops 50s,” one wrote.

The method was simple for a geared mage. Mount through the first area, pull a big group of Devotees, use a large drop in the dungeon to shed aggro, and kill the whole pack with Blizzard. The video that spread the method was posted on Monday with “160+ GPH” (gold per hour) in its title. Its description says the mobs had “full loot” and that “the imps kill themselves,” calling it an “absolute gross oversight” by Blizzard. Near the end, the player’s instance log shows about 25 Blackmaw Hold resets in a single afternoon, from 11:56 a.m. to 6:51 p.m.

It wasn’t only mages. Players said paladins, druids and hunters ran it too, and a slower version in Sunken Temple paid around 60 gold an hour.

Players say it ran for days before the method went public

By the time the video went up, the farm had been quietly making the rounds. The top thread on the subreddit, titled “Exploit early and exploit often,” says players in top guilds had known for days and kept it quiet, and the video’s own uploader opened with “Cat is out of the bag” and told viewers to “enjoy this for the few hours it remains unnerfed.” The thread has more than 2,100 upvotes and 860 comments.

Many of those comments point at Ziqo, a well-known mage streamer. The thread’s screenshot shows 4,322 gold in his bags on stream, and players claim he ran the farm off stream for two days. Ziqo hasn’t addressed the gold total publicly, but on X he pushed back on the idea that it was a mage problem: “u mean the farm that pallys, mages, druid, hunters were doing aka half the classes in the game?” he replied to one critic.

Blizzard turned off the loot but hasn’t listed the fix

Blackmaw Devotees stopped dropping loot on Monday, within hours of the video spreading. “Just nerfed about 10 min ago, mobs no longer drop loot,” one player posted, and the uploader retitled the video “NERFEDDDDDDD.”

Blizzard’s official WoW: Forever hotfix list for November 16 covers fishing racks, Windfury Totem, Vampiric Embrace and a dozen quest fixes, but not Blackmaw Hold’s loot. Blizzard hasn’t posted about the farm anywhere we could find, and hasn’t said whether it considers it an exploit, whether gold will be removed, or whether anyone will be suspended.

Thousands of gold landed in an economy Blizzard kept tight on purpose

The timing is what makes this matter. Blizzard has spent Forever’s first two weeks keeping gold scarce on purpose:

  • Level 60 quests don’t pay the extra gold they paid in Classic, a change Blizzard confirmed was deliberate. It added gold to most quests from level 48 up instead, so there’s no stockpile of quests to cash in at 60.
  • On November 10 it reduced the price vendors pay for crafted Leatherworking, Tailoring and Blacksmithing armor, and cut Iron Grenades to 1 silver 25 copper from 5 silver.
  • Black Market vendors sell some reagents, which players say caps how high prices like Black Lotus can climb.

Against that backdrop, players holding thousands of gold each, barely a week into the level 60 game, have a huge head start. That kind of money lets someone buy every listing of a crafting material or a rare bind-on-equip item, then relist it higher. Early raid consumables, enchants and crafted gear are where it will show first, because the farmers can pay prices most players can’t yet. And every price they set becomes the price everyone else is asked to pay.

There’s a second worry. Players expect “I got it from the Blackmaw farm” to become a cover story for gold bought for real money, which makes Blizzard’s anti-gold-buying enforcement harder. That enforcement already looks rough. One enchanter posted on Reddit that they got a one-month ban after taking tips for enchants, with 600 gold at most to their name, while “people who exploited a bug to farm at least 5k gold” are still playing. We can’t verify the ban, but the post sits at nearly 400 upvotes.

Not everyone thinks it’s the end of the economy. Forever’s realms are huge, and several players argued that a few thousand gold spread across a handful of characters is “a drop in a lake” compared with what the whole server earns, and that the Auction House will absorb it within weeks. Even they agree the people who farmed it are set for a long time.

“Exploit early, exploit often” is the line everyone is quoting

The split on Reddit and Blizzard’s forums comes down to one question: was this an exploit, or just a very good farm? One side says the mobs were plainly broken, Blizzard fixed it within hours, and keeping the gold rewards the people who used it fastest. “If it wasn’t a bug then why did they immediately hot fix it?” one player asked. The other side says AoE grinding mobs is how WoW has always worked, nobody used a third-party tool or a duplication bug, and players shouldn’t be punished for Blizzard’s loot table.

WoW: Forever is still young, and what Blizzard does next, or doesn’t, will shape how players read every overtuned farm that comes after this one.

So what are your thoughts on this? Was it an exploit? Should those who took advantage be punished? Does this taint your WoW: Forever experience?

World of Warcraft: Forever box art
World of Warcraft: Forever
PC (Microsoft Windows)
Game page

Keep up with World of Warcraft: Forever

Track the game for its next reveal, patch or guide, or get the best of the week every Friday.

One email, Fridays. Unsubscribe in one click.

More news

Is this your game? Promote it on Output Lag, clearly labeled and human-approved.